Direct answer without a scored winner
There is no Security Checklist overall removal champion yet, overall score not yet published; see the verification register. Qualitatively: Incogni when automated broker opt-outs are the job; DeleteMe when you want an assisted-support diligence column without an affiliate CTA; Aura when alerts, credit monitoring, and broader identity tooling matter more than listing takedowns alone.
Incogni vs DeleteMe vs Aura in practice
Incogni is positioned as recurring automated removal with a dashboard for request status, Standard/Unlimited/Family plan names verified, with Unlimited adding vendor-stated custom removal across 2,000+ additional sites. DeleteMe stays comparison-only here so we never invent a /go/ button. Aura bundles people-search/data-broker removal help inside adult identity plans that also market 3-bureau credit monitoring, VPN, antivirus, and password manager features, buy that bundle only if those extras are part of your job.
What “420+” and “200+” actually mean
Those are vendor marketing coverage counts from Incogni and Aura pricing pages (accessed 2026-08-09), not independent lab measurements of how thoroughly your data disappears. Brokers rescrape. Listings reappear. Treat counts as scope hints, never as success rates.
Price honesty with volatile captures
Incogni Standard showed $7.99/mo billed annually ($95.88/year) with FAQ monthly individual copy at $15.98/mo; Unlimited $14.99/mo annual; Family $15.99/mo annual; Family Unlimited $22.99/mo annual (2026-08-09). DeleteMe 1 Person showed $129.00 billed annually (~$10.75/mo equivalent) on joindeleteme.com; Couples $229 and Family (4 people) $329 on the same capture. Aura Individual $12/mo annual ($15 monthly), Couple $22/$29, Family $32/$50, Kids $10/$13. Re-verify same-day before recommending; VAT, promos, and renewals can change checkout.
Recurring maintenance beats one-time hope
Incogni marketing states brokers re-list data and the service keeps scanning and resubmitting removal requests, with monthly progress reports advertised on all plans. That matches how people-search clutter actually behaves. Neither automation nor assisted support can promise a permanent wipe; judge tools by whether they reduce your repeat workload.
DeleteMe geography and affiliate integrity
DeleteMe plan cards state U.S. residents only with automatic renewal unless canceled (deleteme.json#deleteme-geography, 2026-08-09). This pack still lists DeleteMe comparison-only: no /go/ button, no invented coupon. Use official pricing for diligence; use Incogni only when you deliberately want the pack affiliate path after free steps.
Aura when removal is only part of the job
Aura adult plans bundle people-search and data-broker removal help with 3-bureau credit monitoring, VPN, antivirus, password manager, and fraud remediation per vendor copy (aura.json#aura-core-features). Buy that bundle when alerts and credit tooling matter, not when you only want a narrow broker spreadsheet replaced.
Will a service erase you from the internet?
No honest product can promise total erasure. News articles, social posts you control, court records, and sites that ignore opt-outs remain. Paid removal is a workload reducer for broker/people-search clutter, not a witness-protection program.
Who should use the finder instead
If you are unsure whether removal, monitoring, or a privacy bundle fits, complete free steps and then use /tools/data-removal-service-finder/. The finder routes by job, not by commission size.